Defence attorney wants Ruel Reid, Fritz Pinnock and co-accused fraud trial dismissed, cites issues with indictment
Mentioned
Analysis
The article concerns a fraud trial of former Education Minister Ruel Reid and others, alleging a scheme to defraud the Ministry of Education and CMU of over $25 million, including corruption and criminal property charges. It also describes defence motions challenging indictment irregularities, which is directly tied to accountability in public office-related misconduct.
Full Article
Defence attorney Hugh Wildman this afternoon called for the dismissal of the fraud trial involving former Education Minister Ruel Reid, citing what he described as a major judicial error.
Wildman, who represents former Caribbean Maritime University (CMU) President Professor Fritz Pinnock, argued that the trial is fundamentally flawed.
He argued that although five individuals are currently on trial, only two of them—Reid and Pinnock—are named on the indictment.
“The trial as it stands so far is a nullity as it relates to the other three accused,” Wildman told the court.
“This cannot be cured because the trial has commenced on an order that does not exist.”
According to him, the issue is significant and cannot be corrected within the current proceedings.
He insisted the matter must be referred to the Supreme Court.
“How can we proceed with this trial? This trial has to come to an end,” he asserted, urging the judge to halt the proceedings.
Wildman's submission came after the prosecution closed the testimony of its first witness—a minister of religion and employee at Jamaica College—who was called to confirm the identity of a deceased individual.
The deceased, the witness’s brother, served as Reid’s driver and died on November 28, 2020, before being buried on December 19.
Following Wildman’s submission, other defence attorneys adopted his argument.
Reid's attorney, Anthony Armstrong, supported the motion, stating that the indictment is irregular.
“The information listed at the back does not contain any charges other than the one listed at the front,” he argued.
The trial involves Reid, his wife Sharen, daughter Sharelle, Jamaica Labour Party Councillor Kim Brown Lawrence, and Pinnock.
The five were arrested and charged in 2019.
They are facing multiple charges, including conspiracy to defraud, corruption, acquiring and handling criminal property, and participating in an arrangement to retain criminal property.
The allegations involve a scheme to defraud the Ministry of Education and CMU of over $25 million.
- Tanesha Mundle
Follow The Gleaner on X, formerly Twitter, and Instagram @JamaicaGleaner and on Facebook @GleanerJamaica. Send us a message on WhatsApp at 1-876-499-0169 or email us at onlinefeedback@gleanerjm.com or editors@gleanerjm.com.
Related Articles
Fake jobs, bogus invoices
A domestic helper unknowingly employed by the Ministry of Education is among the key allegations in the $25-million fraud case involving former Education Minister Ruel Reid and former Caribbean Maritime University (CMU) President Professor Fritz Pinnock. The prosecution outlined its case in the Kingston and St Andrew Parish Court on Thursday, describing a complex alleged conspiracy to siphon public funds through fraudulent contracts, sham employment, and bogus invoices between 2016 and 2019.…
Ruel Reid, co-accused fraud trial now ready to go
AFTER a forced delay on Monday because of the absence of Senior Parish Judge Vaughn Facey, the trial of former Education Minister Ruel Reid, former Caribbean Maritime University (CMU) President Fritz Pinnock, and their three co-accused will return to court today as their multimillion-dollar fraud trial gets underway. With a stand-in judge presiding, Monday was not wasted as administrative matters were addressed to allow the trial to begin smoothly today.…
Ruel Reid, Fritz Pinnock to stand trial
KINGSTON, Jamaica — Chief Parish Court Judge Chester Crooks has just ruled that former senator and education minister Ruel Reid, president of the Caribbean Maritime University (CMU) Professor Fritz Pinnock and several others will go to trial for the allegations of fraud brought against them. Law enforcement agencies in October 2019 arrested and charged Reid, his wife Sharen, daughter Sharelle, Pinnock, and Councillor Kim Brown Lawrence (Jamaica Labour Party, Brown’s Town Division, St Ann) during early-morning raids at their homes in a coordinated strike acting on allegations of financial improprieties in which funds were supposedly siphoned off from the university and the Ministry of Education.…
Reid, Pinnock lose court appeal
KINGSTON, Jamaica — The Court of Appeal on Friday rejected an attempt by Caribbean Maritime University (CMU) President, Fritz Pinnock and Former Education Minister, Ruel Reid to appeal a decision made in the Full Court. Reid and Pinnock are facing charges of breaches of the Corruption Prevention Act, conspiracy to defraud, misconduct in a public office at common law and breaches of the Proceeds of Crime Act in relation to the education ministry and the CMU.…